Scrolling Headlines:

Environmental journalists face challenges under Trump administration -

March 25, 2017

An open letter to the students of UMass -

March 24, 2017

Pat Kelsey informs UMass AD Ryan Bamford of change of heart just 35 minutes before scheduled press conference -

March 23, 2017

Past and present UMass football players participate in 2017 Pro Day Thursday -

March 23, 2017

Pat Kelsey reportedly backs down from UMass men’s basketball coaching position -

March 23, 2017

Students react to new fence around Townehouses -

March 23, 2017

‘Do You Have The Right To Do Drugs?’ debate held in Bowker Auditorium -

March 23, 2017

UMass men’s lacrosse looks to build on three-game winning streak against Brown -

March 23, 2017

UMass softball riding five-game win streak into first Atlantic 10 showdown -

March 23, 2017

Sanzo: Inability to win close games has hurt UMass baseball -

March 23, 2017

Hannah Murphy scores 100th career goal in UMass women’s lacrosse 16-9 win over Harvard -

March 23, 2017

Old age does no harm to indie rock legends The Feelies -

March 23, 2017

A track-by-track breakdown of Drake’s new project -

March 23, 2017

When a president lies -

March 23, 2017

Let them eat steak, and other gender norms I hate -

March 23, 2017

Dissecting Science: Episode Two -

March 22, 2017

Holy Cross 10-run eighth inning sinks UMass baseball -

March 22, 2017

UMass students react to Spring Concert lineup -

March 22, 2017

Letter: Vote yes for Amherst -

March 22, 2017

You don’t have to walk alone -

March 22, 2017

Letter to the Editor: It’s not anti-Semitism, it’s anti-humanity

(emilyd10/Flickr)

To the Editor:

On March 9th, a Letter to the Editor was published about the recent rise of anti-Semitic attacks across the country. I agree with the author: Cemeteries being desecrated and Jewish Community Centers (JCCs) being threatened are serious hate crimes. I agree that action should be taken. However, I disagree that this is specifically a Jewish issue; this is a democratic issue. A response to the anti-Semitism rampant in 19th-century Europe, Zionism is a movement for the creation of and return to a Jewish state. When the author of the Letter to the Editor cited Zionism as the answer to anti-Semitism in America, they implied that Jews should flee to Israel instead of standing their ground to protect themselves. Escaping into a Jewish enclave is not productive. To find a solution, the rise of anti-Semitic attacks should be viewed within a broader context.

Anti-Semitism is one of many forms of bigotry used to assuage the fears of the masses. What do these masses fear? Economic instability, social inferiority, anything that threatens their lifestyles and livelihoods. When fearing decline, these masses voted for a “populist” leader, one who will reclaim the glory of the country and the people. By voting for this man, these masses cling to the past and anything that excuses themselves of responsibility for their own decline. The leader turns out to further undermine the people who voted for him. At their most vulnerable time, he exploits them to satisfy his own way of life. When his voters become more impoverished and more disgruntled due to his antics, he hides. Where does he hide? Behind the “other.” Who is the “other?” Those who do not look like him, act like him, or agree with him; those who do not share the same values or culture as him. Does he physically hide? No, he hides through silence. When 100 bomb threats were called in within the past month, this leader said nothing. When an Indian man in Kansas was murdered and a Sikh man in Washington was wounded and told to “go back to their country,” the leader said nothing. When students from the University of Pennsylvania were exposed as threatening the lynchings of their Black peers, the leader, an alum of this University, did not condemn this action. When seven transgender women were murdered this year, did the leader release a statement? No.

If the so-called leader will not speak out against hate crimes, then who will? The hated. Who are the hated? You. By encasing yourself within a community, whether physical or virtual, of those who share similar identities, you become someone else’s “other.” The leader knows this. He wants us to stay within these groups; it is his way of dividing us. Being divided is what allows him to maintain power.

How do we break the divides? By identifying beyond a specific race, religion, ethnicity, or gender. No matter whether you are Black, white, Jewish, Christian, Muslim, cisgender, or transgender, you are human. Although the author of this letter meant well, imploring for Jews to take action against anti-Semitic hate crimes plays into this divide. I myself am Jewish, yet I do not think of hate crimes against Jews as exclusive to our community. When I think of the Holocaust, do I think of it strictly within Jewry? No. I think of the Holocaust as one of many genocides committed by populist leaders who divided their people into an “us” and “them,” and allowed through the complicity of those who hoped they were not the “them.” When I see another news story about a hate crime, when I hear sexual harassment on the bus, when I hear my friends talk about not being able to use the bathroom of their choice, I do not think of it as their problem. I think of it as my problem.

As a member of humanity every hate crime is a crime against you. As a participant of a democracy, every hate crime is a crime against your liberties. Each hate crime should be treated with equal importance and reacted to with equal diligence.

Rebecca Duke Wiesenberg

Comments
6 Responses to “Letter to the Editor: It’s not anti-Semitism, it’s anti-humanity”
  1. David Hunt 1990 says:

    When “hate crime” after “hate crime” after “hate crime” are shown to be hoaxes, we stop believing you SJWs.

  2. Harrison Shecter says:

    You make a good point about contextualizing recent antisemitism as part of a wave of hate crimes attacking any number of minority groups. That said, this is no reason to minimalize Jewish struggles. I get that you view the holocaust as being about more than Jews and it was, but let’s not forget who the biggest targets were. When you group “all hate” together into one batch you remove the individual character and nature of different hatreds such as racism, islamophobia, sexism, etc. and whitewash them into one vague, dry concept. If your point is that the author should have talked about other hate in America when she talked about antisemitism then you make a valid point.

    However, at times I think you’re putting words in that author’s mouth. She never said anything about Zionism being the answer to antisemitism in America, she said as a Zionist she cares about Jews. There is nothing in there about mass aliya (emigration of American Jews to Israel).

  3. bodo says:

    sounds like an intentionally evasive refusal to apply intersectionality to hate crimes against jews but ok

  4. Not David Hunt says:

    David, by that logic because several pieces of news have been hoaxes, all news must be fake. #FakeNews?

    Also are you saying that Dylan Roof’s attack on a black church wasn’t a hate crime? Was Srinivas Kuchibhotla, an Indian man in kansas, not shot because he was assumed to be a muslim (and obviously thus a terrorist)?

  5. David Hunt 1990 says:

    @”Not David Hunt”:

    Did I say there are no crimes happening because of race / religion / etc.? OF COURSE NOT.

    But when multiple breathlessly-reported events are shown to be hoaxes, it is LEGITIMATE to question whether there is an epidemic.

  6. David Hunt 1990 says:

    OH. LOOKIE HERE:

    Jewish Israeli teen arrested for phoning in JCC bomb threats
    http://www.timesofisrael.com/jewish-israeli-teen-19-arrested-over-jcc-bomb-threats/

    And one other thing. People on the Left are absolutely capable of not only reporting fake “hate crimes” but perpetrating them to make Trump look as though he’s inciting them. Let me be clear: Am I saying this IS the case for ALL incidents? NO. But I absolutely believe people on the Left are missionaries for “the cause” and thus faking things to create an impression of a crisis is absolutely within their capability and motivation.

Leave A Comment