Massachusetts Daily Collegian

A free and responsible press serving the UMass community since 1890

A free and responsible press serving the UMass community since 1890

Massachusetts Daily Collegian

A free and responsible press serving the UMass community since 1890

Massachusetts Daily Collegian

Are public school dress codes teaching girls not to ‘distract’ boys?

(Phil Roeder/Flickr)
(Phil Roeder/Flickr)

It came to my attention recently that public school dress codes are trying to restrict girls more than boys. To gain perspective, I looked at the code of conduct for East Longmeadow High School here in Massachusetts for issues with the dress requirements. At first, I didn’t find any problems.

But I now realize that was the problem.

I’ve been trained to follow the rules of policy ever since I attended public school in second grade. I always made sure my shorts weren’t too short and my tank tops were more than one inch in width, just because I was doing what I was told.

Upon rereading the school’s dress code policy, I noticed that seven out of the eight dress restrictions were directed toward girls. I then researched the dress codes of Monson and Amherst High School and found similar results. Now, this is something worth being angry about. These codes are training girls to not distract boys and to make sure we conform to the stereotypical prejudices we are subjected to.

Everyday Feminism explains in an article, “It assumes that they dress for other people.  Moreover, it assumes that the sexualization is the fault of the girl and not the person sexualizing her.”

Many arguments against this idea express that women are just generally more provocative than men and dress accordingly because of it. But is this really true? Movies and television shows portray women as sexual beings who detract focus from men at work. I think this misogynistic view of women not only affects how men view and treat women in real life society, but also how we teach girls to act and tell them to dress.

Public schools’ sexist dress policies are enabling the stereotypes associated with women’s clothing, behavior and sexuality to be ingrained in the minds of elementary level kids, and these stereotypes stay there beyond high school graduation. I am a victim of such thoughts.

In schools, girls should not be responsible for being “modest” just to make sure boys are comfortable and focused. And there is no “pressure” for girls to dress sexually. Girls don’t dress just for the attention of boys and clothes today do not resemble the modesty the Puritans embodied centuries ago.

In today’s culture, showing shoulder and thigh is not something we should be looking down upon and we’re hurting the self esteem of girls in schools at an early age by portraying that sense of body shaming. We’re not influencing modesty of student focus as a collective here. We’re shaming women’s bodies and favoring male education.

As The Guardian said, “Sending the message to students that girls’ outfits provoke male behavior is a dangerous slippery slope.” It’s true. A girl shouldn’t be responsible for a boy getting distracted in school. We shouldn’t be teaching girls to dress “modestly” for the benefit of boys’ education. We should be teaching boys to exercise self-control.

Karly Dunn is a collegian contributor and can be reached at [email protected].

View Comments (6)
More to Discover

Comments (6)

All Massachusetts Daily Collegian Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • J

    JbOct 3, 2015 at 4:09 pm

    I think the self control you are referring to is not blatantly staring- which I don’t think anyone would advocate against. Also- you’re a college age student, have you forgotten what it was like between the ages of let’s say 13-18? It’s impossible for most kids that age not to be controlled by their hormones. Women should be allowed to wear what they want, but boys will ALWAYS be distracted by that sort of thing. Again- this is not the same thing as behaviors that lead to sexual assault, so let’s please not confuse the two.

    Reply
  • Z

    Zac BearsSep 30, 2015 at 11:06 am

    As amother penis-owner, JB, I’ve learned to exercise self control. It’s not that difficult.

    Reply
  • J

    JBSep 27, 2015 at 11:17 pm

    “comments like that that make me fear for my life while walking home at night.”

    Way to go from 0 to 60. Guys are always going to be distracted by attractive women, it’s not something you can eradicate. To suggest that males being distracted leads to something that would make you fear for your life is absurd. As far as the bicep comment goes- That’s absolutely a false equivalence. There are dress codes in place for both genders, and cut off t’s on guys do not elicit the same response as yoga pants on girls. I’m not even opposed to getting rid of dress codes, but comments like the one above me don’t do any good for anyone.

    Reply
  • S

    SSSep 27, 2015 at 12:41 pm

    This is worded so well and so eloquently. Why should women be restricted from wearing the clothes that are almost exclusively the only type of clothes being sold to them? Also, where are the dress codes for male students? There should be a no bicep or calf requirement, since some girls find that attractive. Kevin (above) says to “teach boys to exercise self-control” is laughable, and as a woman, it’s comments like that that make me fear for my life while walking home at night. THIS is the reason we NEED to teach men not to victimize, rather than teaching women to be sorry that they caused this victimization.

    Reply
  • K

    KevinSep 25, 2015 at 1:29 pm

    Why do people make every issue a “man against woman” issue? Just be glad you’re not a Muslim woman. Now that’s the real “War against women”.

    Reply
  • J

    JbSep 24, 2015 at 11:21 pm

    Well, as a male who knows what it’s like to have a penis, I can safely say that yoga pants are certainly distracting at times. There’s 200,000 years of evolution behind that distraction and I think the “teach boys to exercise self-control” idea is laughable. Look, I certainly don’t want any woman to be shamed for dressing a certain way, and I’m sure there are schools/institutions that take the whole thing way too far, but professional dress codes encompass both men and women. This is really a non issue.

    Reply