Massachusetts Daily Collegian

We’re not hysterical for fighting gun violence

Students protesting are being put down for being immature

Caroline O'Connor

Caroline O'Connor

By Jacob Russian, Collegian columnist

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






In the wake of the tragic school shooting at Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School, a large group of young people have mobilized to advocate for stricter gun control laws in the United States. Despite the sheer amount of grief and loss facing these students, they collectively inspired a nationwide movement aimed toward ending senseless gun violence in this country. The subsequent media coverage of this event garnered attention around the world, thus sparking a debate about how money influences politics in the United States. In particular, the students of Stoneman Douglas criticized the role of the National Rifle Association in blocking gun control legislation through means of intimidation and monetary compensation during a CNN Town Hall program. As intensity grew around this debate, many applauded the young adults for advocating on behalf of their shared interests and experiences, but unfortunately, many adults also chastised the group for their methods and the messages they shared. In fact, numerous conservative political commentators at the Conservative Political Action Conference labeled the advocacy of young people as overly emotional, often citing immaturity as a reason to categorize the group of people as unaware and hysterical.

Ultimately, these criticisms raise an important question in my mind: If adults of older generations consistently label our generation as unmotivated and entitled, why are they so angry when we decide to call for change in this country?

In my personal life, I have often heard these messages from older people as they cite the negative attributes facing our generation. While I do agree that there are certainly things that young people need to work on collectively, I often wonder why it has become so easy for adults to berate younger generations while simultaneously ignoring the issues plaguing their own age group. To me, it seems as though in the eyes of adults, young people cannot do anything right. We maintain a level of entitlement and a lack of motivation, yet when we work toward solving social issues, we are branded as hysterical. This introduces an interesting paradox, one where young people are characterized as never doing enough, yet taking action carries the connotation of immaturity. Much of the criticism facing young people in the fight for gun control centers around citing unfortunate internet trends, like eating Tide Pods, as a way to discredit the work being done. Sane calls for change have repeatedly been overlooked simply because young adults advocating for their beliefs have been lumped in with the disappointing choices of their peers. If grown adults wish that young people would do more with our time, why are they so upset when we actually follow through? How can we expect young adults to take initiative and stifle their independence at the same time?

A common theme amongst commentators following the Stoneman Douglas massacre was that the government should not take policy cues from overly emotional children. Political figure Katie Hopkins stated that she is “tired of them shouting at us with their scripted narrative and Oscar-winning tears,”  to which I would respond with the question: How else are we supposed to bring about change on this issue? Since the horrific Columbine High School shooting and countless other acts of gun violence, the desire of young adults to feel safe in school has been overlooked and ignored. If we cannot effectively organize and perpetuate clear messages of intent, how will anything get done? I often feel as though the idea of youth being synonymous with ignorance is proliferated as a way to discourage young people from being active in politics.

Despite all of the negative attention surrounding young adults as they work for the causes that matter to them, discouragement cannot give way to defeat. If we allow claims of immaturity and hysteria to dissuade us from seeking change, we will continue to fester in the products of an unjust social climate. Whether it is said that young people do too little or far too much, with clear goals in mind, I believe our generation will be able to forge a path forward on the issues we will continue to face. We cannot allow naysayers to denounce the advocacy and intelligence of our generation. The simple fact is that we know what we want, and our youth does not determine our capability of understanding policies that directly affect us.

Jacob Russian is a Collegian columnist and can be reached at [email protected]

3 Comments

3 Responses to “We’re not hysterical for fighting gun violence”

  1. NITZAKHON on April 10th, 2018 3:08 pm

    Almost 50% of the murders in this country happen in 5% of the counties. In fact, if you remove these counties – almost all run by Democrats with stringent gun control – America’s homicide rate drops to one at, or below, most European countries.

    So let me ask you: with abortions every day killing over 300,000 infants – sacrificed in the name of convenience (and with it disproportionately being done by minorities, a racist practice to boot) – where is your priority if lives matter?

  2. R on April 10th, 2018 11:37 pm

    well nik cruz – like most other mass shooters – was an angry white man with sexist, racist and fascist leanings.
    the democratic party has been pouring funds into this supposedly ‘youth-led’ movement so they can keep it safely reformist and steer the youth away from fighting fascism and police violence, which are the only actual youth-led movements that have taken off in this country in the past five years, in part because they immediately went beyond the stale two-party rivalry.

  3. John Aimo on April 11th, 2018 7:14 pm

    The hysteria over ‘gun violence’ is a liberal issue ;it has nothing to do with a youth issue; its just that a small contingent of teenagers are trying to make this into some ‘generational’ issue, typical liberal garb to generalize and act as if they are speaking for a mass of people when in reality its only a small group.

    Look at the recent article of an university of Tennessee student with a photo she has with a gun, clearly she supports gun rights. Look at the school shooting in Maryland(which got almost no media coverage) , a school shooting was stopped by an armed officer; in this case a ‘gun’ stopped massive ‘gun violence’.

    The level of reasoning by liberals is infantile regardless if the person is 16 or 65 and somehow magically thinks that guns make people violent and removing guns will end all violence. The fact is that the majority of murder that exists in our country is not in schools or by those who deranged; but are criminal in nature. If liberals want to reduce gun violence, they need to begin discussing criminal reform and how to make our laws stronger and lock up more criminals in prison.

    Also this column as is all liberal talking points ignores the second amendment; there is a legal and constitutional process which is part of our democracy to change an amendment. It can be done but as long as liberals try to ignore the constitution and force people to give up a legal right; they are going to get nowhere and just face backlash.

    I suggest that if you want to be taken seriously, to take pat in the democratic process and to make your arguments with facts and reason not emotional appeal/manipulation.

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Left
  • We’re not hysterical for fighting gun violence

    Archives

    SGA proposes revisions to the current ‘Land Use Policy’

  • We’re not hysterical for fighting gun violence

    Archives

    UMass swimming & diving to compete in separate invitationals this weekend

  • We’re not hysterical for fighting gun violence

    Archives

    UMass women’s basketball looking to get back on track against Central Connecticut

  • We’re not hysterical for fighting gun violence

    Archives

    Andy Isabella 15 yards away from breaking UMass’ single-season receiving record

  • We’re not hysterical for fighting gun violence

    Archives

    UMass offense looks to find its stride against Central Connecticut

  • We’re not hysterical for fighting gun violence

    Archives

    Course registration is unnecessarily difficult

  • We’re not hysterical for fighting gun violence

    Archives

    White nationalists on the UMass campus

  • We’re not hysterical for fighting gun violence

    Archives

    Americans deserve equal access to voting

  • We’re not hysterical for fighting gun violence

    Archives

    Five successful women to look up to

  • We’re not hysterical for fighting gun violence

    Archives

    Artist to Watch: 070 Shake

Navigate Right