Massachusetts Daily Collegian

The Egyptian Revolution is failing..

By Alaa El-Shafei

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.

Email This Story

Over a year after his downfall, the deposed Egyptian president has yet to be convicted of any crimes. Sadly, it is clear today that celebrations of Hosni Mubarak’s downfall were premature. The revolution’s hard-won freedoms have been steadily pushed back by the ruling military regime. Thousands remain in military prisons with their civil rights suspended while there are protests daily around the country. The protests in Egypt were part of a historic moment in Arab history which demonstrated that individual citizens will organize together to fight for their freedom.

Yet Egypt’s 81 million people are still living under a dictatorship. With a quarter of the Arab league’s population, Egypt is the most important ‘Arab Spring’ country to date. In the Middle Eastern context, Egypt is too important to ignore and so long as the military remains in charge, Egypt will be unstable.

Egypt has taken the first step towards democracy by electing a new parliament. With Egyptian presidential elections just around the corner, the United States must do whatever it can to help the Egyptian people get the freedom for which they have fought and died. The first step is cutting military aid to Egypt.

The United States has a very strong interest in the outcome of Egypt’s revolution.

First, it is in this country’s nature to help freedom and democracy prevail everywhere. A democratic Egypt would go a long way to helping plant the seed of democracy in Middle East.

Second, America has spent over $60 billion in aid to Egypt since 1985. U.S. officials consistently justified this aid as necessary for continuing high level security cooperation, especially counter-terrorism efforts. Today, the U.S. stands at risk of losing this investment. Over two-thirds of the aid money has gone to military aid, creating a situation in which the Egyptian military is dependent on the U.S. military for equipment, training and even funding.

As a result, the U.S. is uniquely placed to influence the Egyptian military. What happens in the next few months, even years, will be essential to determining the revolution’s outcome. The United States must be actively engaged in the country’s transition to a democracy. When the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces in Egypt (SCAF) took the reins of power in February 2011, they promised to hand over executive authority to an elected president by July 2011. Today, the SCAF is still in power, vowing to relinquish presidential authority by July 2012.

There is little reason to trust the SCAF’s promises. Since assuming power last February, the military’s behavior has indicated that it intends to remain the dominant institution in Egypt’s political structure far beyond the current transition period.

In March 2011, there was a constitutional referendum in which voters were presented with a simple yes or no choice. Voting “yes” meant keeping the current constitution while adding or amending nine articles. Voting “no” meant deleting the old constitution and forming a committee to draft a new one. Seventy-seven percent of the country voted “yes.” The military ignored the result and issued its own ‘constitutional declaration,’ essentially writing the rules with which it has governed the country.

In early April, the Egyptian military cleared Tahrir Square with no warning, killing and beating demonstrators in the process. In July, the protesters returned to occupy Tahrir again, and the army cleared them out again in August. The process repeated itself again in September and November. Each time, the immediate reasons for each protest varied, as did the death toll.

One thing, however, has changed.

In Mubarak’s days, only the riot police fought the protesters. Today, they are backed up by the military. Furthermore, the military killed Coptic Christian demonstrators in October and oversaw the massacre of soccer fans in a stadium last January.

In January 2012, former U.S. President Jimmy Carter visited Egypt to observe the third round of elections, which had been monitored by a number of well-known Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs). Speaking on behalf of the NGOs, Carter hailed the elections as evidence of the huge strides Egypt was taking towards democracy. However, he warned that the military intended to remain the most powerful institution in Egypt despite the newly elected parliament.

After he left, the Egyptian government indicted 44 members of various NGOs, accusing them of interfering in Egypt’s sovereign affairs. Of these 44, 16 were American. These Americans have been released under intense U.S. pressure, but some U.S. congressmen have expressed their anger at the whole affair. Some have even called for cutting off all of Egypt’s aid.

That would be unwise. It is true that currently the Egyptian military is the biggest obstacle to democratization. However, Egypt’s government is about to run out of money and has already asked the IMF and World Bank for help. Meanwhile, President Barack Obama has just requested from Congress $1.3 billion in military aid for Egypt, the same as last year.

Instead of cutting the aid altogether, as some have proposed, the U.S. should instead offer Egypt economic aid in place of the proposed military aid. If the newly elected Egyptian parliament accepts this money, then the United States will win the support of the Egyptian people. If the money is rejected, then the U.S. will have achieved two goals at once: cutting a billion dollars from the deficit while weakening Egypt’s military rulers.

As humble college students, what can we do to help the Egyptian revolution? We are in Massachusetts and one of our two representatives in the Senate, John Kerry, is the head of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, giving him a big say in the way America handles its relations with Egypt.

Whether you are a Democrat or a Republican, write Kerry a letter telling him that you don’t want to give the Egyptian military any money. Tell Kerry to give Egypt the financial aid that is needed to avert economic disaster. If the SCAF refuses this aid, then the Egyptian public will blame them for the ensuing economic turmoil. If the elected parliament accepts this aid, then America will have taken the first step to winning the goodwill of the Egyptian people. Above all, tell Kerry that you do not want your tax money to be spent on sustaining a military dictatorship. Tell  Kerry that America supports freedom.

Alaa El-Shafei is a Collegian contributor. He can be reached at [email protected]


8 Responses to “The Egyptian Revolution is failing..”

  1. Maged Eskander on April 9th, 2012 5:20 am

    Nice article, I agree with most of your words, and I believe most of Egyptians agree with your suggestion, however I think its very dreamy.. I wish politics run in this simple ways..

    Maged Eskander
    Egyptian from Egypt


  2. Arafat on April 9th, 2012 9:44 am

    “Egypt has taken the first step towards democracy by electing a new parliament.”

    Is this your idea of a joke?

    What has really happened in Egypt is the Islamists have grown increasingly powerful. And with their increased power comes fewer individual freedoms, i.e., less democracy.

    When will people figure out that Islam and democracy are incompatible, for Islam is inimical to individual freedoms – always has been and always will be.

    The only way people in the Middle East will ever experience democracy is to leave Islam behind and to emulate a country – say, like Israel – that has created a vibrant democracy in its short tenure in the Middle East.


  3. Arafat on April 9th, 2012 9:46 am

    Write John Kerry and tell him not to waste another penny on another failed Islamic country. let the saudis step up to the plate for a change instead.


  4. Alaa El-Shafei on April 9th, 2012 11:47 am

    @Maged: I agree that this is all pipe dream. But people shouldn’t lost sight of the real obstacles to democracy.

    @arafat: I am not happy the Islamists won, but at the end of the day they were voted democratically into parliament. However, if you are worried about them you should ask Mr. Kerry to increase Military aid to Egypt, that way the army will maintain its illiberal dictatorship: no islamists, but no democracy either. And lots of instability.


  5. David Gotthelf on April 9th, 2012 4:33 pm

    Where, under an Islamic regime do the people have freedom the way the West understands freedom? Democracy is not elections. It is a culture – a way of life which does does not exist in the Middle East, except in Israel. Why impose Western concepts on nations which do not understand them and perhaps do not even want them.


  6. Tim on April 9th, 2012 10:53 pm

    I agree with the last comment, we should not be imposing our own version of democracy on all these countries. If we can help them by supporting them with some money, and maybe some training in political organizing as we’ve done in the past, that’s fine, but we shouldn’t be interfering with their affairs as much as we are, even though the budget for next year is projected to increase the state department’s funding by 1.6 percent, thus leading to further interference in Egypt and other arab countries.

    At the same time, though a perfect transition to democracy may be unlikely in Egypt, it’s not a pipe dream to say that we can greatly improve our foreign policy and stop interfering with countries the way we have in the past. Because having outside interference supporting one side or the other, military vs islam, or pushing for a democracy, is not a true democracy at all.


  7. Arafat on April 10th, 2012 12:57 pm


    Islamic dysfunction is NOT our fault, nor anyone esle’s fault other than Islam. Islam is by its very core tenets an undemocratic, freedom-hating “religion”. Individual rights, religious rights, minority rights, free speech and press rights are all anathema to Islam.

    Until Muslims realize that their own worse enemy is their religion we will continue to see one failed Islamic state after another regardless of what we – or anyone else – do to try to make it better.


  8. kerrynut on September 12th, 2012 7:33 pm

    high unemployment, gov going bankrupt and these political idiots are giving our tax money to people killing our ambasaders. insane!


If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.