Massachusetts Daily Collegian

Academia may be a game — but we are not pawns 

Through self-advocacy we can shape our futures 

(Collegian file photo)

(Collegian file photo)

By Tessa Oliver, Collegian Contributor

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






I recently read Dan Riley’s column “Academia is a game — don’t play into it,” and while I understand the cynicism of his viewpoint, I disagree with its sentiment. Academia may be a game, but great students are not the ones who exploit it – they are the students who thrive despite the game, who work within the system to make the best out of their college experience. These students advocate for themselves, engaging in valuable experiences in college that will benefit them long into their future.

Viewing college as an obligation and as a system you have to game takes away your own personal responsibility to pursue your interests and goals. Students are not helpless pawns or players who have to cheat to win. We are in charge of making our own plays through self-advocacy. In fact, many of us don’t even have the luxury or power to sabotage the system, especially minority students, low-income students or students with disabilities who have to learn to work within various systems from a very young age. For many students, the only option is to take advantage of every opportunity and resource that is available to them, from pursuing independent research to using the myriad of resources that the Learning Resource Center has to offer. A lot of students could benefit from this mindset, but it does involve accepting responsibility for your own education. This can be difficult for some people, especially when they don’t know where to start.

College is so much more than the classes we take and the grades we receive, and it is shortsighted and personally harmful to think this way because it takes focus away from the many enriching opportunities outside of the classroom that we pay for with our tuition. I agree that sometimes major and university requirements can feel irrelevant to my interests, but despite those requirements I have been able to have fulfilling experiences here at the University Massachusetts. During my sophomore year, I joined a research lab on campus, and I have learned a lot of skills and built relationships that I never would have had access to in the classroom. I didn’t know the professor I work with before joining the lab; I simply emailed him expressing interest in his research and met with him to discuss becoming a research assistant. I’m now currently working on my honors thesis in the lab and it has been an incredibly rewarding experience. I chose to pursue departmental honors because I knew that taking honors general education courses wouldn’t help me achieve my goals, but that doing a thesis would be helpful for my future career.

Students shouldn’t feel limited by the classes they have to take. If you’re interested in a particular period of history, or are interested in global health and know of professors who do research in those areas, you should reach out to them to discuss your interests, build your network and see if you can work on research projects with them throughout your undergraduate career. You don’t have to be in their class to do this. Most professors enjoy mentoring students, and the worst thing that can happen is they say no. If you want to do research and don’t know how the process of contacting faculty members works, the Office of Undergraduate Research and Studies is a resource that I highly recommend for students.

As a biochemistry major, I try to regularly check out weekly graduate research seminars, where speakers come in from various institutions to discuss their research projects. I also enjoy going to Distinguished Faculty Lectures and Pizza and Prof lectures through the Honors College. There are so many opportunities on campus for academic enrichment – you just have to find them. Many departments have a regular seminar series or journal clubs where you can engage with current research in your field of interest and actively network with graduate students and professors who are doing work in that field. In addition, there are so many offices on campus that can help you achieve your academic goals such as researching abroad, finding a mentor or applying to grants and research scholarships.

When it comes down to it, academia is not really about the classes you have to take – it’s about the critical thinking skills you gain, the people you network with and learning how to be a self-advocate, especially at a school as large and brimming with opportunity as UMass.

I think if there is criticism to be had, it should be in whether our school sets up its students to self-advocate. As someone who works at the Learning Resource Center, we try really hard to reach out to students early on. A lot of departments and offices could do better and there is always room for improvement. But the truth is that a lot of students don’t take full advantage of what is offered to them. Many people have this “college is a game” mindset, and that can really hold you back, especially since we as students have the power to make our time at UMass the best and most fulfilling it can be.

Tessa Oliver is a Collegian contributor and can be reached at [email protected]

3 Comments

3 Responses to “Academia may be a game — but we are not pawns ”

  1. John aimo on April 10th, 2018 2:39 am

    It’s not simply a “mindset” as the the other columnist laid out an argument. Higher education has basically made it a requirement to get a degree to get a decent paying job and has robbed colleges of meritocracy.

    The reason many ‘disadvantaged’ students don’t attend college is because they lack the merit, the intelligence or grades to get in or they prefer not to. I think it’s a disgrace universities have diminished standards and let almost anyone in and based on the x affirmative action/disadvantaged box. It diminishes the value of a degree.

    Have you ever bothered to walk around campus? It’s essentially a garbage pit, It is loud, trash everywhere on the ground and construction everywhere. It’s like the administration went out of their way to make the campus ugly and loud.

    We are paying among the most in the country in tuition for any public college. You could as an in state student attend UNC chapel hill for half the price and get twice the education with a far higher ranking and prestige.

    What do we get at umass? An administration that wants to criminalize students because they like to drink and party, liberal professors who abuse their roles to push an agenda instead of education, “equality/diversity/social justice” social indoctrination, an unbelievably ugly campus, an college with mediocre rankings and for wll that you pay among the highest tuitions in the country for a public university.

  2. Aron on April 11th, 2018 5:59 pm

    https://www.usnews.com/education/best-colleges/the-short-list-college/articles/2016-05-03/10-colleges-with-the-highest-tuition-for-in-state-students

    UMass is not in the top 10 highest tuitions for public universities.

    https://www.umass.edu/newsoffice/article/umass-amherst-modify-admissions-financial-aid-policies-due-affirmative-action-rulings

    UMass changed their diversity requirements away from what you seem to be inferring in 1999.

    https://www.umass.edu/oir/sites/default/files/publications/dept_profiles/campus_summaries/ss00%20Campus%20Summary.pdf

    70% of recent seniors were very satisfied with UMass, 25% were somewhat satisfied.

    It seems like you’re just upset, it looks like the vast majority of people here are having a positive experience.

  3. John Aimo on April 14th, 2018 12:05 am

    According to college board it’s in the top 20, as I stated among the highest in the country. It puts it among the 10 percent most expensive public colleges, considering there are hundreds. So I have no idea idea what your point was.

    The school clearly promotes a diversity and social justice agenda versus academic merit, are you really that ignorant to not know that? It’s the motto of the school not to mention the giant propaganda posters by the art building, mandatory social justice courses and otherwise. It just diminishes from a serious and authentic education.

    What was your survey based on? Based on a poll done by umass? Gee that’s not a biased source. The university has so deprived you of an education your unable to critically discern sources. something even a community college student can do.

    Look at the facts according to government data collected by the department of education, above average transfer rate and below average graduation rate.

    I laid out a reasoned and fact based argument, something most students and professors are incapable of for any subject; of my criticism of the university.

    You just provided misleading data, an outdated policy that is not really relevant, a survey by the college showing how great it is and made an emotional argument.

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • Academia may be a game — but we are not pawns 

    Archives

    UMass Transit Services cuts bus route runs due to shortage in trained drivers

  • Academia may be a game — but we are not pawns 

    Archives

    An early morning adventure in Buddhist prayer

  • Academia may be a game — but we are not pawns 

    Archives

    GIRLS project to provide opportunities for girls to work with co-robots

  • Academia may be a game — but we are not pawns 

    Archives

    UMass football considers upcoming bout with Ohio to be a big test

  • Academia may be a game — but we are not pawns 

    Archives

    The Massachusetts women’s soccer team is a product of Jason Dowiak’s journey

  • Academia may be a game — but we are not pawns 

    Archives

    Johnston: UMass has chance to prove themselves at Ohio

  • Academia may be a game — but we are not pawns 

    Archives

    Letter: Asbestos is a major threat to low-income housing residents

  • Academia may be a game — but we are not pawns 

    Archives

    No retribution for sexual assault after federal overhaul

  • Academia may be a game — but we are not pawns 

    Archives

    Does the Pioneer Valley have a profiling problem?

  • Academia may be a game — but we are not pawns 

    Archives

    Columbia Gas and National Grid failed us; now what?